Portnikov: the Patriarch was no different from President Putin

The letter sent by the head of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church-Kyivan Patriarchate (UOC-KP) Filaret to address the Council of bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church (ROC), and the reaction to it proves the lack of independence of the UOC of the Moscow Patriarchate (MP). About this column to «Radio Liberty» said political commentator Vitaly Portnikov.

«For the first time since independence, the UOC-KP, the Primate of its officially addressed to the bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church with an offer of dialogue, and the proposal was not only considered, but also received a positive response. The Council of bishops formed its own Commission for such dialogue and actually recognized two simple facts: that the UOC-KP is indeed a Church, not a «group of friends», and that the partner in dialogue for this Church organization is the ROC, not the Ukrainian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate)», – he wrote.

Explorer noticed that the Commission was headed by the representative of the ROC and the UOC-MP. According to him, it «emphasized once again who is the real Church Institute, and who the unit consisting of the Institute».

«Since the days of the Apostle Paul the Church is not only religious and moral but also a political organization. In Orthodoxy it is more pronounced than in any other Christian denominations: that is why the boundaries of the churches, as a rule, duplicate the border States. Ukrainian split and the reluctance of the Russian Orthodox Church to grant autocephaly to the UOC – is not evidence of the deep concern of the Moscow Patriarchate on the canonical. It is, above all, the hope that state borders will sooner or later change that Ukraine will return to Russia. And in this hope the Patriarch does not differ from President Vladimir Putin,» – said Portnikov.

30 November, ROC announced that Patriarch Filaret in writing apologized for the Church schism in Ukraine. Some Russian media wrote that it was about the pardon, but in the ROC and the UOC-KP is denied.

«Wanting to end the division and strife between Orthodox Christians, to restore the Eucharistic and prayerful communion, as it should be the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church, for the sake of God bequeathed to the world the same faith between Orthodox Christians and reconciliation between the peoples turn to you with an appeal to take appropriate decisions which will put an end to the current confrontation», the letter said.

The ROC noted that heard the appeal of Philaret and made the decision to establish a Commission to «conduct further negotiations with the breakaway from the Church fellowship».

Filaret said that the appeal was said about reconciliation and about the future of the autocephaly of the Ukrainian Church. He stressed that his letter was used and «sent that we supposedly want to return to the Moscow Patriarchate». He stressed that the Ukrainian Orthodox Church-Kyivan Patriarchate (UOC-KP) will never become part of the UOC of the Moscow Patriarchate.

In Ukraine there is the Ukrainian Orthodox Church of Kiev and Moscow Patriarchate, the Ukrainian Autocephalous Orthodox Church and several churches of other denominations. Yesterday the Russian Orthodox Church officially recognized the independent status of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the Moscow Patriarchate.

Portnikov: the Patriarch was no different from President Putin 02.12.2017

Декабрь 2nd, 2017 by
36 queries